How to Resist Paying the Dinner Bill

10/24/2011

Seriously

Is it ever okay at a restaurant to assume your dinner is going to be paid for by the other party?

Of course.  But these situations have to be approached strategically.  For instance:

 - Never say, “I insist” one too many times. You’ll might win.

 - Make sure you don’t reach for the bill when the presumed paying party isn’t looking. And, if this happens, PLEASE do not try and put it back.

 - NEVER smile and say, “You didn’t have to do that!” UNTIL you are 100% sure the presumed paying party has in fact paid the bill.

Here’s a successful scenario I was in a while back when Tyler’s parents, Bill and Nancy, took  us out to dinner.

Walking into Cheescake Factory:

Me: I’m pretty sure Bill is going to pay for our Dinner.

David: Yeah, but there’s that certain amount of resistance we have to give.

Me: True, and I think I’ll blog about it on Monday.

Finishing up at Cheesecake Factory

Me: I’m so sorry I have to eat and run, but I have a flight to catch.

Bill: We totally understand.

Me: Can I just leave you money for mine?

(I had zero cash in my wallet.  This was risky.)

Bill: No, I’ve got yours.

Me: Are you sure? I can pay.

(No I couldn’t)

Bill: Get out of here.  I’m paying.

Me: (with a dash of surprise) Gosh, thanks so much.

Bill, I know you’re reading this.  I’m sorry for pretending I didn’t know you were going to pay.  Next time you really don’t have to (wink).

, , , , , ,
  • http://Www.ps20.net Ben habeck

    Didn’t you pay for me last time? Oh, wait, that was when you had free chic-fil-a coupons from mr. Cathy!

  • http://volcrazy.livejournal.com brad

    And if i might add…be careful not to offer to just “take care of the tip” if it is a large party…you might end up dropping 8-15 bucks on tip, which negates the “free meal” you just had.

    I’ve found a good rule of thumb is don’t mention anything about tip unless you are sure the total bill falls in the $20 or less catagory…then, you are looking at a maximum $4 payout. I’m glad i’m not the only person who thinks this way!

  • http://kylestevenmusic.com Kyle Bonenberger

    This is hilarious; and it represents my thoughts exactly. Well put.

  • Nancy

    I can’t wait until we eat together again!

  • http://wealthhermit.info/discover-the-simple-secret-to-building-wealth/ Discover the Simple Secret to Building Wealth : Your Wealth Info Guide

    [...] trippcrosby.com » Paycheck Resistance [...]

  • http://missionallendale.wordpress.com/ Joey Espinosa

    Yeah, I’ve made the mistake of presuming someone would pay the bill, when they weren’t intending to. Awkward.

  • http://guidetowomen.wordpress.com Sharideth Smith

    i have friends who always pay. they know they’re going to pay. i know they’re going to pay. i pretend like i’m going to pick up my part every time.

    it’s our thing.

  • http://www.hannahjoiner.com Hannah

    You have totally done this to me. 

  • Jespeseth

    Next time you are in Davenport, IA on your national tour I will gladly pay. You bring me so many laughs for free it is definitely worth it.

  • http://twitter.com/patty7beth Elizabeth Rushing

    X-husband thought he was a master at this. Turned out to be a pattern… ”Let me give you that child support check now …oh, wait, my checkbook’s in the other car.”

  • TorConstantino

    Fascinating! This is a whole new level of moochery. Would it be a sin if I tried to pull this move on our pastor during a Saturday lunch meeting at Chik-fil-A? 

  • http://thomasmarkzuniga.com TMZ

    Seinfeld and “the reach,” anyone? “All I want is a reach!”

  • http://www.trippcrosby.com Tripp Crosby

    Hope it wasn’t your date.

  • http://www.trippcrosby.com Tripp Crosby

    Do they know it’s your thing?

  • http://www.trippcrosby.com Tripp Crosby

    Wow thanks. I won’t forget this offer.

  • http://www.trippcrosby.com Tripp Crosby

    :)

  • http://www.trippcrosby.com Tripp Crosby

    Um… uh. Now I feel awkward.

  • http://www.trippcrosby.com Tripp Crosby

    Do it, and let me know how it goes.

  • http://www.trippcrosby.com Tripp Crosby

    I remember.

  • David Robertson

    The only time I’ve ever been out to dinner with Bill and Nancy was at Cheesecake Factory…and they paid. 

  • http://www.trippcrosby.com Tripp Crosby

    Yep – that’s you.